Which Remember the Titans star would be a better college athlete?

"Listen, I'm Gerry, you're Julius.  Let's just get some particulars and get this over with."

Julius Campbell-

"Honestly, I think you're nothing.  Nothing but a pure waste of God-given talent.  You don't listen to nobody, man!  Not even Doc or Boone!  Shiver push on the line every time and you blow right past 'em! Push 'em, pull 'em, do something!  You run over everyone in this league, and every time you do you leave one of your teammates hanging out to dry, me in particular."

Perhaps one of the most gifted DEs in the history of Virginia high school football.  

He had speed, athleticism, and a knack for getting to the quarterback.  He had great closing speed and made plenty of tackles from behind, illustrating his desire and determination that probably stemmed from the oppressive attitude of the south.  His disruption up front wreaked havoc on opposing teams and led to favorable matchups down the field.  Julius had the perfect frame for a DE, 6-4 and hands the size of saucers.  He reminds me of a raw Mathias Kiawanuka, and would probably be just as effective against the run as the pass.  I'd expect the SEC to take a big interest in him on pure potential alone.

Gerry Bertier-

"You cannot replace a Gerry Bertier... as a player... or person."

As an All-American LB at T.C. Williams, Bertier demonstrated the ability to led an elite defense.  He is a physical, intense player whose skills should translate well to the college game.  Having played in Virginia, it is likely that he would have received offers from Virginia Tech, Notre Dame, Ohio State, and Penn State among others.  Bertier would have excelled at any of those schools.  His passion and drive to compete made him a natural leader.  His college career would have paralleled that of AJ Hawk, Mark Herzlich, or Paul Posluszny.

Conclusion: 

In terms of athletic ability it is clear that Julius Campbell was better, whether it be making plays on the football field or playing ball at the burg.  He had all the natural talent you could ask for.  The question is, in terms of potential would Julius ever fulfill it?  Gerry Bertier was a smart player and a hard hitter.  He made up for his lack of speed by taking good angles and outworking other players.  In terms of a sure thing, Gerry was a guy who had size and knowledge to step in immediately and contribute.  He's a proven winner.  Julius would be the player that would need a year or two to develop and barring any setbacks in bulking up, would be among the top Defensive Ends in the nation.  Look for Bertier to stay all four year and for Campbell to take his pro-potential to the draft after his junior season.  With the extra year under his belt, Gerry would have a more complete college football resume.

Verdict:

Better Athlete in College: Julius Campbell

Better College Football Player: Gerry Bertier